Thanksgiving Pre-sale - CLOSES NOV. 20th

〰️

Click to Order

〰️

Thanksgiving Pre-sale - CLOSES NOV. 20th 〰️ Click to Order 〰️

Where every treat is a happy treat 

Welcome to Happy Oven Bake Shop!

We PROMISE—The treats taste as good as they look!

We are two friends baking delicious treats in the greater Buffalo, NY area. As of right now, we are only selling locally and are not shipping items. All items are available for pickup, in Amherst or Clarence Center, or for delivery, for an additional fee. We hope you can treat yourself or loved ones to something that makes your heart and taste buds happy!

Thanksgiving Offerings

  • Personalized Sugar Cookie Name Cards

    Order by the cookie to have edible personalized name cards on your Thanksgiving table! No minimum order quantity!

  • Thanksgiving Minis

    Perfect for a hostess gift or for everyone to share over a cup of coffee after dinner! Can’t go wrong with these adorable mini sugar cookies!

  • Thanksgiving "Pie" Set

    Bring a special “pie” to thanksgiving this year! This half dozen ( + bonus whipped cream cookie) sugar cookie set is bound to be delicious!

  • Do-It-Yourself Turkey Decorating Kit

    This turkey needs your help to make his feathers beautiful! Grab this kit to entertain the kids while the adults cook or watch football! Comes in 2 sizes.

  • Fresh Baked Rolls

    Want to check one thing off your list to cook this Thanksgiving? Order a batch of fresh baked sourdough rolls for your feast!

Order Now!

Custom Sugar Cookies

We work with you to design the perfect cookies that you are envisioning!

Other Happy Offerings

Cookies, Cakes, and Bread!

  • Straight from the mouths of our Happy Customers

    "If you haven't yet, you have to try the delicious treats from Happy Oven Bake Shop! Everything I have tasted from them has been delicious, especially their custom sugar cookies! To top it off, the owners/bakers are wonderful to deal with and take so much pride in their products! I highly recommend them!" -Shannon C.

  • Straight from the mouths of our Happy Customers

    "These sugar cookies look amazing and taste even better. They are creative and were the perfect finishing touch for our child’s birthday party." -Michael A.

  • Straight from the mouths of our Happy Customers

    "The sugar cookies from Happy Oven Bake Shop are not just cute and very well done, but they taste really good too! The icing and cookie are both delicious!" -Charlene S.

  • Straight from the mouths of our Happy Customers

    "I got cookies for my SIL’s wedding rehearsal and they did NOT disappoint! I wish I could add pictures but they don’t do them justice, they were beautiful and just what I asked for! All the details down to their wedding colors, and last name in the champagne bottle with sparkles! They also tasted phenomenal which is important too! I’d highly recommend them, and will be coming back for future events!! Thank you so much again!" -Kaylee R.

Sweeten Your Inbox!

Sign up with your email address to receive delicious news and updates.